College Counseling: Applying “Everywhere”
By Daryl CapuanoGeneral Education AdviceWhen “Apply to Everything” Becomes the Plan
I have no problem with long college lists. Times have changed.
Indeed, you will find yourself if your guidance counselor is out of step with the times if she suggests applying to a couple of schools in reach, range, and safety mode.
Even that framework is now off.
Last September, a mother from Waterford called us on a Sunday evening. Her daughter, whom we’ll call Maya, was a thoughtful senior with strong grades, two varsity seasons, and a long list of colleges that had grown, in her words, “like a weed.” It had reached nineteen schools. Maya had added a few because friends were applying. A few more were added because a relative said they were “good schools.” Two were there because a ranking website said so.
“We’re not sure how she’ll write nineteen sets of essays,” her mother said. “And honestly, we’re not sure she’d be happy at half of them.”
That second sentence is the real problem. A long list is not the same as a good list. When we sat down with Maya and her parents, we did not start by cutting names. We started by asking what she wanted from college: small seminars, a place where she could keep playing a sport, access to marine science, and a campus she could picture walking across in February. Within a single meeting, the list shrank to nine schools, each one chosen for a reason Maya could say out loud. She wrote better essays because she finally knew why she was applying. By spring, she had a real choice between several colleges that fit her.
Maya’s story is a composite, drawn from families we have worked with, but the pattern is real, and it is one we see across the Connecticut shoreline from Waterford to Old Saybrook. In this article, we want to talk about how many colleges to apply to, how to build a list that is balanced and honest, and how Connecticut families can keep the process from taking over senior year.
What the National Numbers Say About Application Volume
It is worth knowing how the broader landscape looks, because it explains why so many families feel pressure to apply widely. According to the Common App’s End-of-Season Report for 2025-26, 1,527,328 distinct first-year applicants applied to 1,146 member institutions, an increase of 2 percent from the 1,495,475 applicants the year before. Total application volume rose 6 percent, from 10,157,068 to 10,786,782. The report also found that applicants applied to more colleges on average: applications per applicant rose 4 percent, from 6.79 to 7.06.
Read that carefully. The number of students rose by 2 percent, but the number of applications rose by 6 percent. In other words, the typical student is submitting more applications than a year earlier, and that dynamic can make admissions feel more crowded and unpredictable even when the number of students has not changed much. Colleges, in turn, can have a harder time predicting who will actually enroll.
What should a family take from this? Not that you need to apply to more schools. The average of just over seven is a national figure across all kinds of students and states, not a target. It tells us that seven or eight thoughtfully chosen applications is well within the mainstream, and that a list of nineteen is well outside it. For many of the Guilford, Madison, and Essex families we work with, a list of eight to ten schools that cover a true range of selectivity is plenty.
Source: Common App, End-of-Season Report, 2025-2026: First-Year Application Trends (August 20, 2026).
Step One: Start With the Student, Not the Rankings
The most useful college list begins with questions about the student, not a ranked table. Here are the ones we ask in our first sessions.
What does a great day of learning look like?
Some students come alive in discussion-based seminars. Others do their best work in labs, studios, or on teams that ship a product. A student who loves debate may flourish at a liberal arts college of 2,000 students, while a student who wants research with large facilities may prefer a university with graduate programs. The structure of a college shapes the student’s daily experience far more than its name does.
What size and setting feel right?
We encourage students to visit a range of campuses early, even if it is only a short drive. A student from Madison can compare a small campus and a mid-size university in a single weekend, and the contrast often teaches more than a brochure. Some students discover they like the energy of a city. Others realize they need green space to recharge. Many of our Essex and Old Lyme families are surprised to learn how much their children value being able to get home by car or train.
What does the family need to know about cost?
This is a conversation to have early, not in April. Net price calculators on each college’s website can give a rough estimate. Families should talk openly about what they can contribute, what loans are acceptable, and which schools may need to come off the list if the numbers do not work. We would rather have that conversation in October of senior year, or better yet junior year, than discover a gap after acceptance.
What does the student want to avoid?
The “no” list is often more revealing than the “yes” list. A student who knows she does not want a campus where everyone leaves on weekends, or does not want a huge introductory lecture, has already narrowed the field in a meaningful way.
Step Two: Build a Balanced List
A balanced list contains colleges across a range of admission likelihood. Most counselors, including us, describe three loose categories.
Likely schools are colleges where the student’s academic profile sits comfortably above what the college typically admits. They are not throwaway choices. A likely school should be a place the student would be genuinely glad to attend. This is the category families most often underinvest in, and it is the one that protects them from a stressful spring.
Target schools are colleges where the student’s profile is in the middle of what the college typically admits. Admission is reasonable but not guaranteed.
Reach schools are colleges where admission is uncertain even for strong applicants. The most selective institutions are reaches for nearly everyone, however accomplished. The Common App report noted that applications to its most selective members, those with admit rates below 25 percent, grew 3 percent in 2025-26, which is one more reminder that competition at the top remains intense.
A healthy list often looks like two to three likely schools, three to four targets, and two to three reaches. The exact numbers depend on the student. What matters is that every school on the list passes the “would I be happy there?” test, and that there is at least one financially comfortable option on the list.
Why “just one more reach” is a trap
The temptation in November is to add one more reach because the thought of leaving a dream school off the list is painful. We understand that. But each additional application takes real time and attention, and that time comes from the applications that matter most. A student who writes ten strong applications usually outperforms the same student who rushes eighteen.
Step Three: Understand How Testing Fits In
Testing policies have shifted a great deal in recent years, and families need current information rather than rumors. Per the Common App report, the number of applicants who reported a test score grew 11 percent from the previous cycle, while the number who did not report a score decreased 5 percent. For the first time since 2019-20, applicants reporting a score outnumbered those who did not. The report also found that 5 percent of members require a test score to submit an application.
That 5 percent figure is small, but the trend matters. Many colleges remain test-optional, and some of the most selective have returned to requiring scores. Our advice is to plan to test, then decide later whether to submit. A strong score can strengthen an application at many schools, and having the option is better than not having it. We cover the SAT and ACT comparison in a companion article this week. Every family should check each college’s current policy directly on its admissions website, since policies can change from year to year.
Step Four: Choose a Deadline Strategy
Early Decision, Early Action, Restrictive Early Action, and Regular Decision each carry different commitments. Early Decision is binding, which means it only makes sense when a school is a clear first choice and the family is comfortable with the likely financial outcome. Early Action is non-binding and can give a student an earlier answer without a commitment. We discussed this in more detail in our earlier article on early decision versus early action.
For students now in the thick of November, the practical question is what needs to be done between now and the winter deadlines. Here is the checklist we share with our shoreline families.
- Confirm the final list and each school’s deadlines and required materials.
- Finish the main Common App essay and move on to supplements, which are often where students stumble.
- Request recommendations early and thank teachers in writing.
- Complete financial aid forms and the CSS Profile where required, well ahead of deadlines.
- Keep a simple spreadsheet or calendar that shows every deadline, who owes what, and what has been submitted.
Step Five: Protect the Student’s Voice
One of the most important things a counselor does is also one of the least visible: we help students sound like themselves. Admissions readers see thousands of essays. The ones that stand out are rarely the most polished. They are the ones that sound like a specific person with a specific way of noticing the world.
When Maya wrote her essay, her first draft was about winning a big game. The second, after we talked, was about the quiet hour she spent every Sunday cleaning the tide pools near her grandmother’s house in Waterford, and what she had learned by watching the same small ecosystem change through the seasons. It was a smaller story and a far more revealing one. We did not write a word of it. We asked questions until she heard her own voice.
Parents play a vital role here, too. The best thing a parent can do for an essay is to be a first reader who says what moved them, not a second writer who edits for style. We coach parents on this because the line between supporting and taking over is a thin one, and everyone is under pressure in the fall.
Step Six: Keep Perspective
Senior year is not only an application. It is the last year students spend at home, with friends they have known since elementary school, and in classes that still count. We remind families that colleges care how a student finishes the year. We also remind them that the admissions outcome, whatever it is, does not define a student.
We have worked with families across Guilford, Madison, Essex, Old Lyme, East Lyme, Waterford, and Old Saybrook for more than two decades, and we have supported clients across the country and internationally, particularly in Central America, who apply to U.S. colleges from very different school systems. The through-line is consistent. The students who do best are not the ones who apply to the most colleges. They are the ones who understand themselves, build a list with intention, and tell the truth about who they are.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many colleges should my child apply to?
There is no magic number. The Common App’s 2025-26 report found that applicants averaged 7.06 applications, which gives a useful benchmark rather than a rule. For most students we work with, eight to ten well-researched schools, balanced across likely, target, and reach, is a healthy range. Quality matters far more than quantity.
When should a Connecticut family start working with a college counselor?
Many families begin in the spring of junior year, which leaves time to build a list, plan testing, and draft essays over the summer. Starting earlier, in sophomore or early junior year, helps with course selection and activity planning. Starting in the fall of senior year is still possible and often very helpful, but the timeline is tighter.
Is it a problem if my child applies to a lot of reach schools?
A list made up mostly of reaches is risky, because even outstanding students are not guaranteed admission at highly selective colleges. We aim for every student to have several schools they love and are likely to get into.
Should my child submit test scores to test-optional schools?
It depends on the score relative to the college’s typical range and on the rest of the application. Check each college’s current policy and consider submitting a score that helps the application. A counselor can look at the whole picture and give a specific recommendation.
Can a college counselor help with international applicants or families outside Connecticut?
Yes. We regularly work with students across the country and internationally, including families in Central America, through video sessions, shared documents, and regular check-ins.
Ready to Build a College List That Fits?
If your family is on the Connecticut shoreline or anywhere else, and you want a calmer, clearer path through the college process, we would be glad to talk. Contact The Learning Consultants to schedule a conversation about your student’s goals, timeline, and next steps.
Sources
- Common App, End-of-Season Report, 2025-2026: First-Year Application Trends, August 20, 2026: https://www.commonapp.org/files/DAR/deadline-updates/2025-26/Common-App-End-of-Season-Report_25-26.pdf
Anecdote note: Maya and her family are a composite and anonymized.
The Learning Consultants is Connecticut’s top educational consultancy. Providing guidance to families facing high-stakes educational issues and tutoring in every major subject area.

CEO, The Learning Consultants and Connecticut’s top private education consultant
full bio

