SAT v. ACT
By Daryl CapuanoGeneral Education AdviceNot too long ago, the ACT was gaining traction as a contender for the dominant standardized test. But it had some issues during its transition to the digital format. And, in Connecticut, at least, the SAT became mandatory for Connecticut high school students.
So… of late, the SAT has been the dominant test – by far – for most Connecticut test takers.
Which One Is Easier?”
A Guilford mother emailed us in October with a question we hear every fall. Her son, whom we’ll call Ethan, was a junior who had taken a practice SAT at school and felt rushed on the reading passages. A friend had told her the ACT was “easier” and “more straightforward,” and Ethan had asked whether he should switch.
“I don’t want him to waste months studying for the wrong test,” she wrote. “How do we even decide?”
We suggested something unglamorous: before changing anything, have Ethan take one full, timed practice test of each exam under realistic conditions and compare not just the scores but the experience. Which one felt more manageable? Where did he run out of time? Where did he make careless errors versus real content errors? When the results came back, Ethan’s scores on the two tests were close, but his experience was not. He felt more in control on the SAT’s shorter, digital format and simply needed to practice pacing. He stayed with the SAT, and his preparation became far more focused. His mother told us the best part was no longer worrying that she had picked wrong.
Ethan is a composite, but the lesson applies to many students in Guilford, Madison, Old Saybrook, and across the Connecticut shoreline: the question is not “which test is easier?” It is “which test fits this student, and how do we prepare efficiently?”
First, Does Your Student Need to Test at All?
Many colleges are test-optional, but the landscape is shifting, and it is worth checking each school’s current policy on its admissions website. According to the Common App’s 2025-26 End-of-Season Report, 5 percent of its members require a test score to submit an application. The same report found that the number of applicants reporting a test score grew 11 percent from the previous cycle while the number not reporting decreased 5 percent, and that applicants who reported scores outnumbered those who did not for the first time since 2019-20.
What does this mean for a family? Five percent is a small share of colleges, but some of the colleges in that group are highly selective, and the trend toward score reporting suggests many students believe a good score helps. Our advice for most students is to prepare for one test, take it, and then decide whether to submit based on the score and each college’s policy.
Source: Common App, End-of-Season Report, 2025-2026: First-Year Application Trends (August 20, 2026).
The Basics: How the SAT and ACT Differ
Both tests are accepted widely. College Board’s BigFuture page says most U.S. colleges accept scores from either exam for admissions decisions, course placement, financial aid, and scholarships, though a family should always confirm with each college. Here is how the two exams compare based on College Board’s published comparison and recent coverage of the ACT’s changes. Note that these sources were published in 2025, so you should check the current details on the official SAT and ACT websites before registering.
Length and pacing
According to College Board, the SAT is 2 hours and 14 minutes, with 98 questions, about 1 minute 22 seconds per question, divided into a Reading and Writing section and a Math section. The ACT, according to the same comparison, has 131 questions in 125 minutes without the optional Science section, about 57 seconds per question, and 171 questions in 165 minutes with it.
Pacing is often the deciding factor. A student who likes to think carefully about each question may feel more comfortable with the SAT’s more generous time per question. A student who prefers to move quickly and does not mind a faster rhythm may prefer the ACT. Neither is better in the abstract. It depends on the student.
The optional Science section
College Board notes that starting in spring 2025 the ACT’s Science section became optional, and that the optional Science score does not count toward the composite ACT score. Collegewise, writing in April 2025, explained that the composite is an average of the three core subjects: English, Math, and Reading. It also noted that many schools have said they will not require the Science section, though students should verify each college’s policy.
Format
College Board describes the SAT as digital for everyone, with paper for students with related accommodations. Collegewise reported that the ACT rolled out a digital version in April 2025, while College Board’s page said national ACT testing is paper in most places. Availability varies, so check the ACT’s current registration information for what is offered at your student’s test center.
Scoring
The SAT is scored on a 400 to 1600 scale. The ACT uses a 1 to 36 scale. Colleges may treat the two similarly when evaluating an application, but families should look at each college’s published ranges for admitted students.
A Decision Process That Works
Here is the process we use with students from Waterford to Old Saybrook.
- Take a full-length, timed practice test of each exam. Use official materials, find a quiet space, and keep to strict timing. Do not skip sections.
- Compare more than the score. Notice which test felt more manageable, where time ran short, and which mistakes were fixable.
- Check the target colleges’ policies. Confirm whether each college requires, recommends, or is optional about testing, and whether it accepts both tests. If a school has a particular policy about the ACT Science section or score reporting, note it.
- Choose one test and commit. Splitting preparation across both tests rarely helps. A focused plan on one test usually beats a half-effort on two.
- Set a realistic timeline. Most students need several months of steady preparation, working backward from the test date they want.
There is one situation where a student may want to try both: if the practice results are very close and neither feels clearly better. In that case, an extra practice test or a short trial of preparation for each can help break the tie.
Building a Smart Preparation Plan
Once a student chooses a test, the plan matters more than the test.
Start with a diagnostic
A full practice test shows strengths, weaknesses, and pacing issues. It also gives a baseline to measure progress against.
Target the biggest gains first
Students often improve fastest by fixing a small number of recurring errors, such as a specific grammar rule, a type of algebra problem, or a habit of misreading the question. We look at the pattern of missed questions rather than the overall score.
Practice in the real format
Because the SAT is digital, practice on the digital format. Familiarity with the interface, the on-screen tools, and the pacing removes a source of avoidable stress. Our tutors build practice sessions around timed sections and careful review of every miss.
Review, do not just do
Taking practice tests without reviewing mistakes is one of the most common reasons students plateau. The learning happens in the review: why did I miss this, what will I do differently, and can I explain the correct approach aloud?
Protect the student’s well-being
Test preparation should not take over a student’s life. Sleep, exercise, and time with friends affect performance, and a steady rhythm of short sessions usually beats last-minute cramming. We encourage families on the shoreline to keep the rest of junior year, including sports, music, and school, in balance.
When to Take the Test
Timing depends on the student’s schedule, course sequence, and target colleges. Many students take their first official test in the spring of junior year, leaving room for a retake in the summer or fall. Students who finish the relevant math coursework earlier, or who want to apply early to certain colleges, may start sooner. College Board and ACT publish test dates, and registration deadlines come well before the test, so plan backward from the date you want. Check the official calendars for current dates.
We also encourage students to think about whether a retake is likely. Many students improve on a second attempt after focused preparation, and knowing that a retake is possible can reduce the pressure on the first one.
How Parents Can Help Without Hovering
Parents are often the ones who first raise the SAT or ACT, and their support matters. Here is what we suggest.
- Help your student set up a schedule and protect the time, but let the student own the work.
- Ask about how the preparation feels, not only about scores.
- Avoid comparing your student’s score to a friend’s. Scores mean different things for different colleges.
- Treat the test as one part of the application. Grades, course rigor, essays, activities, and recommendations all matter.
Serving Connecticut and Beyond
The Learning Consultants has tutored and advised students in Guilford, Madison, Essex, Old Lyme, East Lyme, Waterford, and Old Saybrook since 2000. We also work with students across the country and internationally, particularly in Central America, through online sessions that adapt to different time zones and school calendars. Students in those settings often face their own challenges, such as limited local test dates, and we help them plan around them.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the ACT easier than the SAT?
Neither is easier in general. The tests have different formats, pacing, and question styles, and students tend to do better on one or the other depending on how they work. A timed practice test of each is the best way to find out.
Do all colleges accept both tests?
According to College Board, most U.S. colleges accept scores from either exam. Confirm each college’s policy on its admissions website.
Is the ACT Science section still required?
College Board states that the ACT’s Science section became optional starting in spring 2025 and that the optional Science score does not count toward the composite. Individual colleges may have their own preferences, so check the policy of each school on your list.
How long should a student prepare?
It varies, but most students benefit from several months of consistent preparation, with a diagnostic at the start and regular practice tests along the way.
Should my child submit scores to a test-optional college?
That depends on the score compared with the college’s typical range and on the rest of the application. The Common App reported that more applicants submitted scores in 2025-26 than the year before, but each college’s policy and context are different. We help families decide case by case.
Can you tutor students who live outside Connecticut?
Yes. We work with families across the country and internationally through video sessions, shared practice materials, and regular progress reviews.
Let’s Find the Right Test and the Right Plan
If you are deciding between the SAT and ACT, or you want a focused plan to raise your student’s score, The Learning Consultants can help. Contact us to schedule a diagnostic and a conversation about your student’s goals and timeline.
Sources
- Common App, End-of-Season Report, 2025-2026: First-Year Application Trends, August 20, 2026: https://www.commonapp.org/files/DAR/deadline-updates/2025-26/Common-App-End-of-Season-Report_25-26.pdf
- College Board BigFuture, “SAT vs. ACT: Which Test Should I Take?” (undated; footnote references ACT information as of February 2025): https://bigfuture.collegeboard.org/plan-for-college/apply-to-college/sat/sat-vs-act
- Collegewise, “New Enhanced ACT Exam Changes Guide,” April 14, 2025: https://collegewise.com/blog/new-enhanced-act-exam-changes-guide
- Previously researched (rotation log): College Board, “How Scores Are Calculated” for the SAT 400-1600 scale.
Editor’s note: ACT and SAT format details come from 2025 sources. Verify current details on the official ACT and College Board sites before publishing. Anecdote: Ethan and his mother are a composite and anonymized.
The Learning Consultants is Connecticut’s top educational consultancy. Providing guidance to families facing high-stakes educational issues and tutoring in every major subject area.

CEO, The Learning Consultants and Connecticut’s top private education consultant
full bio

