Early Decision and Early Action… decisions are coming… what’s your plan?
By Daryl CapuanoGeneral Education AdviceDeferred or Waitlisted? What Connecticut Students and Parents Should Do Next
A note on the story below: the families we describe in our articles are composites, with names and details changed to protect privacy. The patterns, however, are very real.
“It Wasn’t a Yes, and It Wasn’t a No”: A Story from Madison
Every December, we meet some version of the same family. One recent example was a student from Madison we’ll call Priya, who had applied early decision to her first-choice university. Her mother, Anita, called us the afternoon the decision posted. “She’s been staring at the screen for an hour,” Anita said. “It says ‘deferred.’ We don’t know whether to celebrate or grieve.”
Priya had spent months preparing. She had visited the campus twice, written a thoughtful essay, and told friends and teachers where she was headed in her heart. Now she was stuck in limbo. Her mother, meanwhile, was torn between wanting to protect her daughter and wanting to fix the situation immediately. Anita was drafting emails to the admissions office before we even spoke.
We asked them to pause for a day. Then we worked through a plan. First, we read the deferral notice closely to learn exactly what the college asked of deferred students. Second, we helped Priya identify what new and honest information she could share: a strong fall semester, a leadership role she had taken on in a community project, and a meaningful update about her intended major. Third, we built a short, respectful letter of continued interest in Priya’s own voice. And fourth, and just as important, we sat down with the family to make sure Priya’s regular-decision applications to several other schools she genuinely liked were polished and on time.
Priya did not stay frozen. She stayed active and she stayed balanced, which is exactly what the best responses to a deferral look like. The rest of this article explains how to do the same.
Deferred vs. Waitlisted: Two Different Situations
Families often use the two words interchangeably, but they describe different moments in the process. According to ACT’s guide to deferrals and waitlists, published in July 2026:
- Deferred means a college has postponed the admission decision and will review the application again during the regular admission period. It happens in the early decision or early action rounds, and ACT says it implies potential in the applicant but calls for further review.
- Waitlisted is described as neither an acceptance nor a rejection. It means the student meets the admission criteria but the offer is on hold because of space. It occurs in the regular admission process, when a college has filled its slots but might admit more students if space opens up. Waitlist offers usually come after May 1.
ACT also notes that a deferral is generally more promising than a waitlist, because a deferred application gets a second review, often with a chance to submit additional material, while a waitlist depends on admitted students declining and spots opening.
One more point that surprises many families: according to the same guide, early decision applicants generally cannot be waitlisted in that round. The possible outcomes are acceptance, rejection, or deferral, and a student who is deferred from early decision may later be waitlisted in the regular round.
Both outcomes are a delay, not a verdict, and both reward calm, organized action.
Why Colleges Defer and Waitlist Students
It helps to understand the institution’s point of view. Colleges are building a class, not just evaluating individuals. A deferral often means the admissions office wants to see more: new grades, fresh test results where applicable, and a clearer sense of how the applicant compares with the rest of the pool. A waitlist is a way for colleges to manage uncertainty about how many admitted students will enroll.
ACT’s guide describes waitlisting as a precaution colleges use to fill their classes, which makes being waitlisted better than being denied. That framing is accurate, but it is also worth being honest: outcomes vary widely between colleges and from year to year, and some colleges publish statistics about deferred and waitlisted students while others do not. Use the information a school provides, and be realistic about the odds.
Your First 72 Hours: What to Do (and Not Do)
1. Take a breath and read the notice carefully
Deferral and waitlist messages usually contain specific instructions: whether you must confirm that you want to remain under consideration, what documents you may send, and by what date. Following the college’s directions exactly is the single most important step. Some schools ask students to respond within days.
2. Do not panic-email the admissions office
Parents in Madison, Guilford, and Essex are understandably protective, but flooding an admissions office with calls and messages rarely helps and can hurt. ACT’s guidance is to keep updates regular and respectful, and to follow college instructions about contact. Let your student lead the communication.
3. Give yourselves a day before deciding anything big
A deferral or waitlist notice is emotional. A short pause before action prevents rash choices.
4. Make sure your contact information is current
ACT recommends using a dedicated personal email account, not a high school address that may not be available after graduation, and confirming that colleges have the correct address on file.
5. Reaffirm your backup plan
This is the step that many families skip. ACT calls choosing a backup school especially crucial for waitlisted students, given the uncertainty and tight timelines. If you have not finished your regular-decision applications, they become your top priority now.
How to Strengthen a Deferred Application
A deferral is an invitation to be considered again. Here is how students can make the most of it.
Write a thoughtful letter of continued interest
A letter of continued interest (sometimes called an update letter) reinforces your commitment and provides new information. A strong one is short, specific, and sincere. It should:
- Thank the admissions office for the continued consideration.
- State clearly that the college remains a top choice, and mean it. (If you applied early decision, you have already made a binding commitment, and you should reaffirm it.)
- Share concrete updates since you applied: new grades, awards, projects, leadership roles, or experiences.
- Connect those updates to something specific about the college, such as a program, professor, or community that fits you.
- Stay positive in tone. Avoid complaints, comparisons to other applicants, or anything that sounds entitled.
Send only meaningful updates
Ask whether each piece of news actually adds something. A new leadership role or a meaningful improvement in grades helps. A long list of small items does not.
Consider additional materials only if the college invites them
Some colleges welcome additional recommendations or updated test scores. Others discourage extra material. ACT’s guide suggests improving your application through additional activities, a stronger GPA, or retaking a test, but the right choice depends on the school’s policies. Always check before sending anything.
Keep your grades strong
Fall and winter semester grades matter. A deferred student who finishes the semester with strong performance gives the admissions office what it most likely wants to see.
How to Respond if You Are Waitlisted
The waitlist is a different kind of waiting, and it often extends into spring.
Decide whether you want to stay on the list
Many colleges ask students to confirm their interest. Respond as instructed, and only if the college would truly be a good choice for you.
Write your letter of continued interest
As with a deferral, a concise, sincere update can reinforce your interest. Be honest about your enthusiasm, and do not exaggerate.
Commit to a school you love by the deadline
Waitlist offers usually come after May 1, and early action admits have until May 1 to decide, according to ACT. That means students often have to commit, and pay a deposit, to another college before they know the waitlist result. Pick a school you would be happy to attend. If a waitlist offer arrives, you can reconsider with a clear head.
Understand that practices vary
ACT notes that some colleges rank waitlisted students, while others fill spots based on institutional needs. Appeals are generally not encouraged, and visits should follow the college’s guidance. Waitlists typically have no limit, so be realistic about your odds, costs, and level of interest.
What Parents Can Do
Parents play an important role at this moment, and it is mostly a role of steadiness.
- Absorb the disappointment first. Your teen will take emotional cues from you. Calm, matter-of-fact support communicates confidence.
- Avoid blame. There is rarely a single reason for a deferral, and speculating about what went wrong helps no one.
- Focus on next steps. Help your student create a checklist and timeline, then step back and let him or her do the work.
- Keep perspective. A student who is genuinely happy at any of several good colleges has far more options than a single decision suggests.
- Watch for signs of distress. If your teen is withdrawing or struggling to cope, reach out to your pediatrician or a mental health professional. We are educational consultants, not clinicians, and we will gladly coordinate with the professionals you trust.
Build a Balanced List Before Decisions Arrive
The best time to prepare for a deferral or waitlist is before it happens. A balanced list typically includes schools where your student’s credentials are strong, schools that are a realistic match, and a few ambitious choices, all of which the student would be happy to attend. The Common Application publishes data on how many colleges applicants submit to, and its 2025-26 end-of-season report showed an average of 7.06 applications per applicant, up from 6.79 the prior year. Those national averages are not targets for any one family, but they do show that most students spread their applications across multiple schools.
Along the Connecticut shoreline, from Guilford and Madison to Old Saybrook, Old Lyme, East Lyme, and Waterford, we help students design lists that reflect their academic profile, their interests, and their family’s financial picture. We have been doing this since 2000, and we work with clients across the country and internationally, particularly in Central America. If you are a family abroad applying to American colleges, the deferral and waitlist processes are the same, and the importance of a clear plan is even greater when you are working across time zones.
A Sample Timeline for Deferred Students
- Within 3 days: Read the notice, note deadlines, and discuss the situation as a family.
- Within 1 week: Draft a letter of continued interest and gather meaningful updates.
- Throughout December and January: Finish all regular-decision applications and keep grades strong.
- February and March: Send one thoughtful update if the college permits additional communication.
- By May 1: Commit to a college you are excited about.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between deferred and waitlisted?
Deferred means the college has postponed its decision and will review your application again, usually with the regular applicant pool. Waitlisted means you meet the admission criteria but the college has no space at the moment and may offer a place later if spots open up.
Should I write a letter of continued interest?
In most cases, yes, as long as the college allows it. Keep it short, specific, and sincere, and include meaningful updates.
Can I still apply to other colleges after a deferral?
Yes. ACT recommends applying to other colleges. If you applied early decision and are deferred, check the terms of your agreement and the college’s policy, and continue to complete your regular-decision applications.
Do deferred students ever get accepted?
Yes, some do, but rates vary widely by college and by year. Some colleges publish deferral statistics, and we encourage families to look for them on each school’s admissions website.
Is it worth appealing a decision?
ACT notes that colleges generally do not encourage appeals, though policies vary. Check the school’s published guidance before doing anything.
Can The Learning Consultants help with this?
Yes. We help students interpret their decision notices, plan their next steps, write effective letters of continued interest, and finish a strong set of regular-decision applications.
Need a Plan? Let’s Talk.
A deferral or waitlist decision can feel like a setback, but with the right plan it can also be a chance to show a college how much you want to be there. Whether you live in Madison, Guilford, Essex, Old Saybrook, Old Lyme, East Lyme, or Waterford, or in another state or country, The Learning Consultants can help. Contact us today to talk through your student’s next steps.
Sources
- ACT. (2026, July 29). What Does Deferred Mean? A Guide to Deferrals and Waitlists. https://www.act.org/content/act/en/students-and-parents/college-planning-resources/applying-to-college/deferred-or-waitlisted.html
- Common App. (2026, August 20). End of Season Report 2025-26 (applications per applicant figures; previously reviewed for this blog).
The Learning Consultants is Connecticut’s top educational consultancy. Providing guidance to families facing high-stakes educational issues and tutoring in every major subject area.

CEO, The Learning Consultants and Connecticut’s top private education consultant
full bio

